August Comte - Revision history

Michael at 15:22, 6 November 2025

2025-11-06T15:22:23Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:22, 6 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|234x234px\|The august August Comte]]~~Auguste~~ Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had ~~utopian~~ ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of creating a [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] that would maintain human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests) and shape “the general direction of this world,” thus ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> In contemporary terms, he was attempting to design an operating system for human society.		<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|234x234px\|The august August Comte]]August Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had Utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of creating a [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] that would maintain human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests) and shape “the general direction of this world,” thus ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> In contemporary terms, he was attempting to design an operating system for human society. He even founded a new religion, the [[Religion of Humanity]], designed to provide the [[Intellectual Order]] and [[Moral Order]] that would support and sustain his Utopian aspirations.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 16:17, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T16:17:18Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:17, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|234x234px\|The august August Comte]]Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] ~~capable of maintaining~~ human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests)~~, shaping the~~ “the general direction of this ~~world”~~ ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> ~~Essentially~~, an operating system for human society.		<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|234x234px\|The august August Comte]]Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of creating a [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] that would maintain human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests) and shape “the general direction of this world,” thus ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> In contemporary terms, he was attempting to design an operating system for human society.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 16:15, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T16:15:54Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:15, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> Essentially, an operating system for human society.		<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|234x234px\|The august August Comte]]Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> Essentially, an operating system for human society.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 16:15, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T16:15:13Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:15, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">~~[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|293x293px\|The august August Comte]]~~Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” ~~His project was openly~~ utopian. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' ~~that would help create a~~ [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> ~~In contemporary terms~~, ~~he was attempting to design~~ an operating system for human society.		<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> Essentially, an operating system for human society.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 16:15, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T16:15:11Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:15, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” ~~He had~~ utopian ~~ambitions~~. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> ~~Essentially~~, an operating system for human society.		<blockquote class="definition">[[File:August Comte.png\|thumb\|293x293px\|The august August Comte]]Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” His project was openly utopian. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' that would help create a [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> In contemporary terms, he was attempting to design an operating system for human society.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 16:10, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T16:10:49Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:10, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of ~~reclaiming what he called~~ “the general direction of this world” and ~~of “constitut[ing] at length a~~ real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref>		<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is considered a founding father of Sociology and is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, materialist, and historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” He had utopian ambitions. From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' / [[The Regime\|Regime]] / [[Mode of Life]] capable of maintaining human unity (even in the face of antagonistic class interests), shaping the “the general direction of this world” ensuring human progress and “a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref> Essentially, an operating system for human society.
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Michael at 04:00, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T04:00:43Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:00, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of reclaiming what he called “the general direction of this world” and of “constitut[ing] at length a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.”~~<nowiki>~~<ref>Auguste Comte, ''The Catechism of Positivism'', trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref~~></nowiki~~>		<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of reclaiming what he called “the general direction of this world” and of “constitut[ing] at length a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.” <ref>Auguste Comte, <nowiki>''</nowiki>The Catechism of Positivism<nowiki>''</nowiki>, trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref>
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Line 21:		Line 21:
	In Comte’s reading of modern European history, the long revolution begins when the medieval spiritual power breaks down, and it will not close until a new, positive spiritual authority reinstates a binding moral rule capable of making divergent industrial and class interests converge. Without that authority, interests oppose one another; with it, they can be “contained within limits.” That is why the creation of a new '''spiritual/moral powe'''r is an '''essential component''' of the long revolution, not a later embellishment. A new spiritual power ensures that the general point of view is institutionally present in society, so that particular class interests, market logics, and administrative routines are continually recalled to common ends and made to converge rather than collide		In Comte’s reading of modern European history, the long revolution begins when the medieval spiritual power breaks down, and it will not close until a new, positive spiritual authority reinstates a binding moral rule capable of making divergent industrial and class interests converge. Without that authority, interests oppose one another; with it, they can be “contained within limits.” That is why the creation of a new '''spiritual/moral powe'''r is an '''essential component''' of the long revolution, not a later embellishment. A new spiritual power ensures that the general point of view is institutionally present in society, so that particular class interests, market logics, and administrative routines are continually recalled to common ends and made to converge rather than collide

	==== Essay Three: Plan of the Scientific Work Necessary for the		==== Essay Three: Plan of the Scientific Work Necessary for the Reorganization of Society ====
	Reorganization of Society ====		In Lesson/Essay Three, the ''opuscule fondamental'', Comte argues that the post-revolutionary crisis cannot be solved by political improvisation because it is at root an intellectual–spiritual vacuum: Europe destroyed its old doctrinal system without creating a new one. Social reorganization therefore requires politics itself to become a positive science (“social physics”) and to begin with a theoretical/spiritual series of works that will formulate the new coordinating principle; only on that basis can a second, practical/temporal series distribute powers and build institutions. Attempts to restore the medieval order are impossible because the crisis is the product of six centuries of civilization. The modern, urban/industrial “new system” is already dominant in detail; what remains is to complete its conquest in the temporal sphere and, above all, to found morality on observation — i.e. to create a new spiritual authority able to direct the whole.

	==Notes==		==Notes==

Michael at 01:21, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T01:21:06Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:21, 3 November 2025
Line 20:		Line 20:

	In Comte’s reading of modern European history, the long revolution begins when the medieval spiritual power breaks down, and it will not close until a new, positive spiritual authority reinstates a binding moral rule capable of making divergent industrial and class interests converge. Without that authority, interests oppose one another; with it, they can be “contained within limits.” That is why the creation of a new '''spiritual/moral powe'''r is an '''essential component''' of the long revolution, not a later embellishment. A new spiritual power ensures that the general point of view is institutionally present in society, so that particular class interests, market logics, and administrative routines are continually recalled to common ends and made to converge rather than collide		In Comte’s reading of modern European history, the long revolution begins when the medieval spiritual power breaks down, and it will not close until a new, positive spiritual authority reinstates a binding moral rule capable of making divergent industrial and class interests converge. Without that authority, interests oppose one another; with it, they can be “contained within limits.” That is why the creation of a new '''spiritual/moral powe'''r is an '''essential component''' of the long revolution, not a later embellishment. A new spiritual power ensures that the general point of view is institutionally present in society, so that particular class interests, market logics, and administrative routines are continually recalled to common ends and made to converge rather than collide

			==== Essay Three: Plan of the Scientific Work Necessary for the
			Reorganization of Society ====

	==Notes==		==Notes==

Michael at 00:54, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T00:54:46Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:54, 3 November 2025
Line 15:		Line 15:
	==== Essay One General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819) ====		==== Essay One General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819) ====
	In '''“General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819)''' Comte argues that modern political turmoil is not mainly about clashing interests but about a basic confusion of levels. At the level of '''desires''', societies are surprisingly unified: most people want peace, security, material improvement, and some measure of liberty. The trouble begins at the level of '''opinions''', where people start prescribing the ''means'' to reach those widely shared ends. For Comte, means are not obvious and cannot be supplied “by instinct”; they belong to a distinct, scientific order of knowledge that has to be worked out by a competent intellectual/spiritual authority. He criticizes the rising urban/industrial bourgeoisie for assuming that, because they are the active class of the new era, they can also reorganize society “by instinct alone” — as if practical energy and social science were the same thing. They are not. Until modern societies '''institutionalize the separation''' between legitimate popular desires (ends) and scientifically grounded opinions (means), politics will oscillate between popular impatience and class presumption, with neither able to produce durable order. In germ, the essay already contains Comte’s later solution: create an independent spiritual power, grounded in positive science, whose specific job is to determine and teach the means, while leaving desires and execution to other social strata		In '''“General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819)''' Comte argues that modern political turmoil is not mainly about clashing interests but about a basic confusion of levels. At the level of '''desires''', societies are surprisingly unified: most people want peace, security, material improvement, and some measure of liberty. The trouble begins at the level of '''opinions''', where people start prescribing the ''means'' to reach those widely shared ends. For Comte, means are not obvious and cannot be supplied “by instinct”; they belong to a distinct, scientific order of knowledge that has to be worked out by a competent intellectual/spiritual authority. He criticizes the rising urban/industrial bourgeoisie for assuming that, because they are the active class of the new era, they can also reorganize society “by instinct alone” — as if practical energy and social science were the same thing. They are not. Until modern societies '''institutionalize the separation''' between legitimate popular desires (ends) and scientifically grounded opinions (means), politics will oscillate between popular impatience and class presumption, with neither able to produce durable order. In germ, the essay already contains Comte’s later solution: create an independent spiritual power, grounded in positive science, whose specific job is to determine and teach the means, while leaving desires and execution to other social strata

			==== Essay Two: Summary Appraisal of the General Character of Modern History ====
			In his second early essay Comte reads European “modern history” as a '''long revolution''' set in motion as soon as the complete Catholic–feudal order (spiritual + temporal) coexisted with the rising '''communes''' (urban/bourgeois towns) from the 11th century onward. Once the two medieval powers began to quarrel, “decadence” was certain; the communes then acted as a third force, allying with one branch of the temporal power to break the other, in France as well as in England. '''The Reformation''' finished the job by overthrowing spiritual unity and by legitimizing criticism. Beneath these surface struggles lay two deeper, irreversible drivers — the advance of '''science''' and '''industry''' — which made a theological–military regime structurally untenable. The result, Comte says, is an “inevitable era of anarchy” whose length matches the scale of the transition and which can only be closed by creating a new, positive spiritual power.

			In Comte’s reading of modern European history, the long revolution begins when the medieval spiritual power breaks down, and it will not close until a new, positive spiritual authority reinstates a binding moral rule capable of making divergent industrial and class interests converge. Without that authority, interests oppose one another; with it, they can be “contained within limits.” That is why the creation of a new '''spiritual/moral powe'''r is an '''essential component''' of the long revolution, not a later embellishment. A new spiritual power ensures that the general point of view is institutionally present in society, so that particular class interests, market logics, and administrative routines are continually recalled to common ends and made to converge rather than collide

	==Notes==		==Notes==

Michael at 00:32, 3 November 2025

2025-11-03T00:32:13Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:32, 3 November 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{navmenu}}		{{navmenu}}
	<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>		<h1 class="customtitle">{{FULLPAGENAME}}</h1>
	<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for ~~founding~~ the ~~discipline of sociology~~ and ~~developing~~ the ~~theory~~ of Positivism. Comte~~'s work emphasized~~ the ~~application~~ of ~~scientific methods~~ to the ~~study~~ of ~~society~~, ~~aiming~~ to create a ~~coherent system~~ of ~~knowledge that could guide social~~ and ~~political reform~~.		<blockquote class="definition">Auguste Comte (1798-1857) was a French philosopher and sociologist, best known for coining the term [[Sociology]]<ref>Anthony Giddens, ''Sociology'', 9th ed. (Polity Press, 2021).</ref> and for formulating the doctrine of [[Positivism]]. Comte is generally associated with the shift from theological and metaphysical speculation to a rigorously empirical, historically grounded understanding of human and social life. However, his ambitions were much larger than “method” or “epistemology.” From his earliest political writings to the <nowiki>''Catechism of Positivism''</nowiki>, Comte aimed to create a '''[[Comprehensive Framework]]''' capable of reclaiming what he called “the general direction of this world” and of “constitut[ing] at length a real Providence, in all departments—moral, intellectual, and material.”<nowiki><ref>Auguste Comte, ''The Catechism of Positivism'', trans. Richard Congreve (London: John Chapman, 1858), Preface, p. 1–2.</ref></nowiki>
	</blockquote>		</blockquote>

Line 7:		Line 7:

	{{#ask:[[Is a term::August Comte]]}}		{{#ask:[[Is a term::August Comte]]}}

			== Writings ==

			=== Early Political Writings<ref>Comte, Auguste. ''Comte: Early Political Writings''. Edited by H. S. Jones. Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought. Cambridge University Press, 1998.</ref> ===
			The '''early political writings''' collected in ''Comte: Early Political Writings'' (ed. H. S. Jones, Cambridge, 1998) bring together Comte’s 1819–1824 texts written before the ''Course of Positive Philosophy'', when he was still working out the political implications of Positivism. In these essays Comte already diagnoses modern Europe as caught in a prolonged transition from the medieval Catholic–feudal order to a new industrial, scientific order; he argues that this “long revolution” cannot be resolved by constitutional tinkering or reactionary restorations, but only by completing the “scientific work necessary for the reorganization of society.” He sketches the law of the three stages, defends the need for an ''independent spiritual power'' distinct from ''temporal/industrial power'', and insists that political direction must rest on a comprehensive, positive doctrine. Read together, these writings show that Comte’s later Religion of Humanity was not an afterthought but the maturation of a project visible from the start: to rebuild a unifying intellectual–moral authority for modern society on an empirical, sociological basis.

			==== Essay One General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819) ====
			In '''“General Separation between Opinions and Desires” (1819)''' Comte argues that modern political turmoil is not mainly about clashing interests but about a basic confusion of levels. At the level of '''desires''', societies are surprisingly unified: most people want peace, security, material improvement, and some measure of liberty. The trouble begins at the level of '''opinions''', where people start prescribing the ''means'' to reach those widely shared ends. For Comte, means are not obvious and cannot be supplied “by instinct”; they belong to a distinct, scientific order of knowledge that has to be worked out by a competent intellectual/spiritual authority. He criticizes the rising urban/industrial bourgeoisie for assuming that, because they are the active class of the new era, they can also reorganize society “by instinct alone” — as if practical energy and social science were the same thing. They are not. Until modern societies '''institutionalize the separation''' between legitimate popular desires (ends) and scientifically grounded opinions (means), politics will oscillate between popular impatience and class presumption, with neither able to produce durable order. In germ, the essay already contains Comte’s later solution: create an independent spiritual power, grounded in positive science, whose specific job is to determine and teach the means, while leaving desires and execution to other social strata

	==Notes==		==Notes==